Questions which are phrased as example seeking, “throughout history”, or other types aimed at generating collections of trivia are permitted only in the weekly trivia thread. We do not permit trivia seeking or homework help posts. Confine these to the weekly trivia thread.

These questions are inherently unsourceable, and invite subjective answers that do not meet with our expected levels of rigor. This includes “what-if” questions, alternative history, or counterfactual scenarios. If such a conflict were to break out, questions or discussion on the conflict would not be permitted until one year after. A question asking about how such a peer conflict would play out is not permitted. A question or post describing how the United States has prepared for a potential peer conflict with the People’s Republic of China is permitted. Questions about current doctrine are permitted, provided they are not speculative about the future effects or implications of said doctrine. We do not permit posts speculating on or questions asking for speculation on future events. We do not do not accept posts discussing events less than one (1) year in the past, as information about these events is still very fluid, hard to verify, and difficult to discuss with our expected levels of rigor. R/WarCollege exists to discuss settled military history, doctrine, and theory.

Rule 1: Questions should be focused on military history and theory. Participation comes first, and you don't have to be an expert to answer a question asked (as long as you can provide sources when asked we have a handy guide as to how to write an answer here). Share a military history video! Post that essay on the Battle of Jena, or teach about a nation's style of warfare, discuss the upsides and downsides of infantry doctrines through the ages. Questions, essays, interesting links, or book reviews about a topic are welcome here. r/Warcollege exists is to educate about and discuss military history, from the ancients to Operation Iraqi Freedom and the Ukraine Hybrid War.

The price of glory alistair horne